Red brick building facade with a recessed dark door, stone steps, and a curtained window.

In the North End, the Broker Fee Question Now Gets Settled Before the Listing Goes Up

A complaint to the Massachusetts Attorney General's Office concerned an apartment listing online that offered two options: pay half the broker's fee, or accept a rent that was $100 a month higher. The apartment was not taken. WBUR reviewed the complaint in May 2026, along with a series of similar complaints.

The complaint is useful for owners because it shows the two workarounds that no longer hold. Under Massachusetts General Laws c. 112, § 87DDD½, a year after the law changed, the broker fee on a North End rental is the landlord's cost whenever the landlord brought the broker in. Under the Massachusetts Attorney General's guidance, it can't be moved onto the applicant through an informal open listing, and it can't come back as a line in the rent. For a small owner, that turns the fee into a decision made before the unit is ever shown.

The Rule, in One Sentence

Since August 1, 2025, Massachusetts law has required a rental broker's fee to be paid only by the party who originally engaged and contracted with that broker. Renters can still hire their own broker to search for them and represent them, and in that case the renter pays. A single broker can't represent both sides.

The state's guidance closes the obvious side doors. A landlord can't require a renter to pay a landlord-hired broker as a condition of a viewing or a lease. The same fee also can't be renamed as an administrative, selection, finder's or leasing fee.

Situation Who pays the broker
Owner lists the unit with a broker Owner
Renter signs a written agreement hiring a broker to search for them Renter
Renter contacts the owner's broker through an online listing Owner
Owner sends the unit to several brokers with no exclusive contract Disputed in practice; the AG says the lack of a formal contract alone does not let the broker charge the tenant

The last row is the one that matters most in a neighborhood like this one.

The Open Listing Was the Old Pass-Through

For years, a common way to fill a small building was to send the vacancy to several brokers without an exclusive agreement and let whoever produced a qualified tenant collect from that tenant. Some brokers have kept that model going under the new law. Their argument is that because no written contract with the landlord exists, the broker is really looking to be hired by the prospective tenant.

The Attorney General's Office answered that argument directly in a statement to WBUR:

"The fact that no formal contract exists with a landlord is not enough for a broker to charge a fee to a tenant."

Todd Kaplan, a senior attorney at Greater Boston Legal Services, takes the same position more concretely. When a landlord gives a broker information about a unit and agrees to consider the applicants that broker brings, Kaplan says that exchange is the contract, written or not, and the landlord owes the fee. The renter-side FAQ points the same way. A tenant who reaches a landlord-hired broker through a listing does not take on the fee by doing so.

No court ruling settling the open-listing question turned up in our research. For an owner, the practical effect is that sending a unit out informally no longer moves the cost to the applicant. It may simply leave the fee unpriced until someone files a complaint.

Why the North End Feels This More Than a Tower Does

The law applies to every landlord in the state, but it doesn't land evenly. Large managed complexes generally lease with in-house staff or under formal agreements. The North End's housing is mostly in smaller buildings. Adding up American Community Survey 2019–2023 estimates for the census tracts that make up the neighborhood puts about 22% of housing units in 2–4-unit buildings, about 32% in 5–9-unit buildings and about 16% in 10–19-unit buildings. That is roughly seven in ten units in buildings under 20 units. These are tract-based estimates, not a published neighborhood figure.

Greg Vasil, CEO of the Greater Boston Real Estate Board, put the statewide picture this way in September 2026: more than 60% of Massachusetts rental housing is owned by small owners, and "many of them aren't connected with any organization where they can learn the latest and update themselves on the law." He also said the early coverage, which described broker fees as "totally abolished," started an education process that is still "a work in progress."

Put those two facts together and the North End's exposure is clear. The kind of owner the board describes as least likely to have kept up with the rule is the kind of owner who holds most of the neighborhood's rental units.

The Rent Bump Is the Second Closed Door

The other instinct is to raise the rent enough to cover the fee over the lease. The Attorney General's guidance allows a landlord to set the rent for a new tenancy with proper notice. It does not allow a broker-fee surcharge, or rent structured to pay back a broker's fee.

So rent has to be set the usual way, against what comparable units in the building and on the block are renting for. The "half the fee or $100 more a month" offer in that WBUR complaint is the arrangement the guidance describes, because it ties the rent directly to the fee. Broker fees are often about one month's rent. For an owner of two or three units, that means one month of rent per turnover has become a fixed leasing cost, much like a vacant month, and it belongs in the annual budget, not in the conversation with an applicant.

The Paperwork Moved With the Fee

The fee notice and disclosure requirements stayed in place and became more important. A lease-up done properly now leaves a paper trail at three points:

  1. At the first personal meeting. The regulations at 254 CMR 7 require a fee notice signed by the broker and the prospective tenant. It has to state the fee amount, the payment terms and whether the fee is owed if no tenancy results, and the broker has to keep it for three years.
  2. Before the lease is signed. State guidance calls for written disclosure of who hired the broker, who pays and how much.
  3. In the listing itself. Kaplan recommends that renters ask directly whether a listing is an MLS listing and who the MLS broker is. An owner whose unit appears under several brokers' names is likely to get that question and should have a consistent answer.

The cost of getting this wrong is not small. Under the Massachusetts Consumer Protection Act, Chapter 93A, a tenant may be entitled to triple the amount of any illegal fee paid, plus attorney's fees and costs. NBC Boston reports that brokers who violate the rule can face fines, license suspension or loss of their license, and civil penalties.

What the 2026 Lease Cycle Added

September 1, 2026 was the second big turnover date since the rule took effect, and renters went into it with some leverage. On the eve of September 1, 2026, NBC Boston reported apartments still available across the area, landlords cutting prices or offering incentives, and renters being offered one or even two months free. In a market like that, an owner who was counting on the tenant to cover the broker could end up absorbing both the fee and a concession on the same unit.

Enforcement attention also grew over the year. In May 2026, WBUR reported that the AG's office had received more than a dozen complaints. On May 21, 2026, Governor Healey and Attorney General Campbell publicly warned that renter-paid fees for landlord-side brokerage services are unlawful. The AG's office said it had obtained refunds and fee waivers through its consumer assistance process and often resolves complaints without formal enforcement. By September, NBC Boston was reporting "hundreds" of complaints. The official material we reviewed showed no formal enforcement case or lawsuit, only that the office often handles these complaints through refunds and waivers.

FAQ

Can a North End renter still pay a broker? Yes. A renter who hires a broker to search for them and represent them can agree to pay that broker. The broker then represents the renter and can't also represent the landlord.

Can an owner raise the rent between tenants? Yes, with proper notice. What the guidance rules out is rent structured to reimburse a broker's fee or a separate broker-fee surcharge.

Where do complaints go? Renters who believe they were charged improperly can file with the Attorney General's Office. This post is general information, not legal advice. Owners with a specific arrangement in question should talk with their own attorney.

If you own a few units in the North End and the next vacancy is coming up, True North Boston Realty handles leasing and tenant placement with the fee arrangement, notices and disclosures set up before the first showing. Contact Us to go over how your next lease-up should be organized.

Discover the Difference

We are committed to guiding you every step of the way—whether you're buying a home, selling a property, or securing a mortgage. Whatever your needs, we've got you covered.

Follow Me on Instagram